O’Grady provided all three goals in Hartwick’s 3-0 shutout victory over Appalachian State on Saturday. He scored on a header in the 6th minute for what would prove to be the game-winner. O'Grady then provided an insurance goal in the 86th minute with a shot from in the box that deflected off the post and into the net. In the 88th, his hat-trick was complete as he headed in a free kick. He leads the Sun Belt in goals (10), points (20), and game-winning goals (4) this season.